Assault & Battery is a Lesser included Offense of Rape

Recently in an unpublished opinion the Appeals court ruled that Assault & Battery is a lesser included offense of Rape in COMMONWEALTH vs. PERDITE SCOTT MEMORANDUM AND ORDER PURSUANT TO RULE 1:28 COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS APPEALS COURT

The court in ruling stated “The defendant, Perdite Scott, was convicted of rape (second offense), assault with intent to rape, and assault and battery. On appeal, he argues that (1) the jury instructions failed to convey the essential elements of the charges against him; (2) the trial judge failed to give a specific unanimity instruction, and the convictions on the lesser charges are potentially duplicative of the rape conviction;

Duplicative convictions. As the issue of duplicative convictions was not raised at trial, we review this issue to determine whether there has been a substantial risk of miscarriage of justice. More particularly, we evaluate the evidence, and the instructions, to determine the risk that the defendant may have been convicted of cognate offenses based on a single act. See Commonwealth v. Berrios, 71 Mass. App. Ct. 750, 754-755 (2008). Convictions of multiple cognate offenses not based on separate and distinct acts violate double jeopardy principles. See Commonwealth v. Vick, 454 Mass. 418, 431 (2009).

Assault and battery is a lesser included offense of rape, see Commonwealth v. Richmond, 379 Mass. 557, 562 (1980); Berrios, supra at 753, but we conclude that there was ample evidence of separate acts, particularly the smacking and choking of the victim prior to the rape, and adequate argument by the Commonwealth regarding those separate acts, to avoid a substantial risk of a miscarriage of justice.

As for the assault with intent to rape, the Commonwealth argues only that it is not a lesser included offense. As we have previously held that it is, albeit without parsing the elements of the two crimes, we conclude that this conviction must be vacated. See Commonwealth v. Kruah, 47 Mass. App. Ct. 341, 347 (1999) (‘[t]he crime of assault with intent to rape is a lesser included offense of rape’); Commonwealth v. Westbrook, 58 Mass. App. Ct. 692, 700 (2003) (‘[b]y finding the defendant guilty of the lesser included offense of assault with intent to rape, it is clear that the jury did not believe that the defendant had penetrated the victim’)”

About Attorney Ronald A. Sellon

Ronald A. Sellon is a licensed Attorney in the state of Massachusetts and U.S. District Court, Massachusetts as well as a Sergeant with a Municipal Police Department and U.S. military Veteran. Additionally, he has taught Criminal Procedure at the Massachusetts State Police Academy in New Braintree and has written a text on Criminal Procedure for police field training officer programs. He is a graduate of the FBI National Academy, was a 2008 recipient of the Massachusetts Coalition of Police (Mass C.O.P.) Presidents award and holds a Bachelors Degree in Law Enforcement, a Masters Degree in Criminal Justice Administration, and a Juris Doctor Law Degree. Questions related to content material may be directed to
This entry was posted in Criminal Law & Procedure, General. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s